Bud, Not Buddy
by Christopher Paul Curtis

Wednesday, February 6
If you submitted a comment about Bud, Not Buddy on February 6, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:

January  22 23 24 25  28 29 30 31 
February  1 4 5 6 7 8 11  12 13 14 15 


 
From:
chris
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
i think it was funny when Bud drove away mr. lewis's car
From:
Steph
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: everyone!
I liked Chapter 11. I agree with Chris I also think it was funny when he drove off with Mr. Lewis's car. I think that Bud will find his dad in Grand Rapids....what do you think?
From:
chris
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
i thought that mr. lewis was a vamire at first
From:
chris
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
i meen vampire
From:
Julie
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Billy H.
Hey, what do you think of the book? I think that it's pretty darn good. Do you think that the book will end up that he will find his father again and find Deza again? I think so. What do you think Billy? I think it would be interesting if Bud lost his suitcase and then he had to go back to find it. That would be very interesting. Then it would be cool if Deza found it and then Bud would ask her out. I enjoy the way the author has the characters interacting and meeting once again after a long period of time. Do you agree Billy? I think the coolest part of the book will always be when he gets a pencil stuck up his nose, all the way up to the r in Ticonderoga. I think Todd is a very mean boy and should go to the home and live there forever because he is so mean. Or Todd can go live with the vampire bats in the shed. Deza is in love with Bud and Bud is in love with Deza. Do you agree with me on that one Billy? I think that dude is annyoung the on e that keeps callin him Bud-not-Buddy. That is getting very innoying. Don't you aree with me Billy?
From:
Steph
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: anyone
I think that this book is really good....one of the best I've read. The only thing that I don't really like about it is how he always says Shucks....anyone agree??
From:
Tom
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: everybody
I liked when Bud drove off in Mr. Lewis's car for a moment I thought he was a vampire.
From:
Lindsay
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Shawna
I think that Herman E. Calloway is Bud's dad. I think that when Mr. Calloway see's but he will, be surprised, & I dont think that he will reconize him at first. What do you think?
Wright back soon.
From:
Nick
Grade 6
Barrington Elementary
Upper Arlington, OH
To: anybody
I wonder if the "vampire" dude really knows Herman E. Calloway or if he's just lying to get Bud (not Buddy) into the car. What do you think?
From:
Nick
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: everybody
Sorry, I'm not from Barrington, I'm from Stillwater, I Just forgot to change the school.
From:
Carmen
To: Everyone: Important Message
Hi! I want to thank you for your great comments yesterday! MOST of them were thoughtful and interesting.

I just have to remind a few of you of one thing. It's never OK to make rude comments to another student on this message board. Everyone has a right to be treated with respect. Everyone's point of view matters. Most of you know this.

It's kind of a waste of time to write rude things anyway; our webmaster will just delete rude remarks as soon as she sees them. We don't need that stuff cluttering up our brilliant message board!

Anyway, sorry to sound bossy. Like I said, most of you know the rules. So, let's move forward with our discusion of this great book!

From:
Raoul
To: Everyone
Wow—Carmen means business. I agree with her. Be nice!

OK. On with the discussion. Michael and Maria—I agree with you. Lefty and his family are really special people. Reaching out to a stranger like they did can be a risk, but the risk is worth it if you're helping out a nice kid who just needs a break.

Let's discuss some of the challenges Bud faces in the story. How does the setting add to these challenges?

From:
Carley
Grade 6
Sheridan Elementary
Petoskey, MI
To: Maria
yes,
I agree with you.
From:
Cookie Monster
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Elmo
Hi,
What do you think Bud learned about families?
From:
Christine
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Antonella
I think that Bud will find his dad in the end of the story and it will turn out to be someone he already knows. What chapter are you on? I'm on chapter 14. Write back
From:
Claire
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Jessi
Are you done the book? I am. I couldn't put it down.Herman took the fact that his little girl died really hard and I think if there is a second book, Bud, Not Buddy, Herman and Bud will have a good life together.
From:
The Rock (Jefffffffffffffffffffffff
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Chris Jericho
Hey I like when Bud steals the car.
From:
Alycia
Grade 6
Barrington Elementary
Upper Arlington, OH
To: Rebecca
I was just wondering if you are done the book and if you liked it. If you read up to chapter 13 do you think that Herman Calloway is really Buds father.Please write back.
From:
Claire
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Jessi
Do you think Herman is Bud's father. I don't. He is too old. If he was his father, he is kind of mean.
From:
Carley
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Maria
Hi,
Do you think that Buds father is herman E Callaway?
From:
sabrina
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: carmen
* Hi*

It is sabrina. No i do not think that Herman E. Calloway is Buds father. Do you think that he is his father? I think why he is not his father is because he is too old to be his father. Another reason why he could not be his father is because he just does not seem nice anough. I think Bud feels really good.
From:
Claire
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Jessi
Do you think Herman is Bud's father. I don't. He is too old. If he was his father, he is kind of mean.
From:
Danielle
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Jenn
Hey Jenn
What do you think of Mr.Lewis and his faimly taking Bud in to thier house for a while?
I thought it was very nice of them.
Please write back telling me how you are liking the book etc.!! Your friend Danielle
From:
Trevor
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Clint in Stillwater
No I do not think Herman Calloway is his farther .I think he his related but not his father . Please please please please
write back.
From:
Nicole
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: To anyone!
I think that Mr.Lewis is Bubs father. Does anyone else think that to?
From:
Danielle
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Jenn
Hey Jenn
What do you think of Mr.Lewis and his faimly taking Bud in to thier house for a while?
I thought it was very nice of them.
Please write back telling me how you are liking the book etc.!! Your friend Danielle
From:
caitlyn
Grade 6
Barrington Elementary
Upper Arlington, OH
To: Antonella
Hey Antonella,
I agree with you when you think that the man in the flyers is Bud's dad. I mean it has to be his dad, if it wasn't his dad then why did his mom keep the flyers and why did she get so emotional?
From Caitlyn
From:
Jordan
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Steph in Stillwater
Hi Steph, I don't think Herman E. Calloway is Bud's father but I do think he is related to Bud.
P.S. please write back.
From:
Kate
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Everyone
I like the Bud not Buddy book. Incase you don't know, this book holds the adventures of Bud the main carecter. He gets into a lot of trouble. He also make some new friends. This book is also very funny!
From:
Matt
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Frank
I think Herman E. Collaway is not Bud's dad because he is way too old and has lots of wrinkles.
From:
Nicole
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: To Chris
I first thought the same thing!I want to find out if Bud ever makes it to Grand Rapids.See Ya!
From:
Brittany
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Danielle
I also thought that was nice of Mr.Louis to take Bud in like that. Do you think Bud is going to find his dad? Where if you do?
From:
nathan
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: anyone
No I don't think Herman E. Caloway is Bud's father because he seems so insistent that Bud is not his son. I think he is Bud's uncle.
From:
Jack
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Josh in Stillwater
I think Herman .E. Calloway is not his dad because he is so mean to Bud all the time. Ms. Thomas is nice though.
From:
Trevor
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Clint in Stillwater
No I do not think Herman Calloway is his farther .I think he his related but not his father . Please please please please
write back.
From:
matt
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Frank,stillwater
what do you think???? Do you disagree with me?

Write Back Please

From:
Brittany
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Chris from Stillwater
I also thought Mr.Louis was a vampire. Why did you think that?
From:
Brittany
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Steph
I agree!!
From:
Nicole
Grade 6th
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: To Steph
No hard feels but I don't agree with you,because thats what makes the book so good!But I don't like who he says woop,zoop,sloop.
From:
jake
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: carmen
Hi

you are write about not writing rude coments

From:
Andrew
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Carmen
Hello
I hope that the people that made the rude coments do not do that again
From:
Alicia
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: anyone who is willing to write back and answer me
Hey,
How does everyone like this book so far? I like it alot because it is very exciting and interesting.
What do you think?
Please write back.
From:
Alex
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Anyone
I don't think Herman Calloway is Bud's Dad because in the book he does not I repeat he does not sound like Bud's dad at all and he is always mean and rude to Bud.

P.S.Write back if you feel like it.

From:
Mike
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Carmen and Raoul

I don't think Herman E. Calloway is Bud's father because is always rude to Bud. Herman doesn't like Bud in his big house because he doesn't want Bud stealing anything in the dead little girl's old room. Bud thinks that he doesn't have any time to talk to Herman E. Calloway.
Please write me back!
From:
Jake
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: anyone
Hello

Do you think Herman E Calloway is his father? Well I don't because he is not treating Bud very nicely and he is rude to Bud. That's why I dont think it's his father.

PS.Write back

From:
Alyssa
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Sara from Stillwater
Yes I think that it was very nice of Bud's pretend family to let him sleep there and give him some food to eat for breakfast.Do you think that Herman E. Calloway is Bud's father? I don't think that he is Bud's Father. I think that he is someone else that is related to him. What do you think? What do you think that Bud is saying when he says he is carrying his mother inside of him? I think that he is carrying her in his heart and trying to remember all of the things she did with him. Do you have snow there? We have a lot!
From:
Andrew
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Chris at Still water Elementary
Hello
I think that someone should tell Bud that there are no such things as vampires or monsters. I think that Heman E. Calloway is not Bud's father but I think that they are related in a way I think that Herman is Bud's grandfather.
What chapter are you on?

From:
Alex
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Nicole in stillwater
I think you are wrong about Mr.Lewis being Bud's father? Why do you think that he is his father?

Please write back.

From:
Alicia
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: anyone nice enough to write back
I think Herman Calloway is not Bud's father because Lefty Lewis said that Herman had another child that is full grown.
What do you think?
Somebody please write back no one ever answers me.
From:
Alyssa
Grade 6
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario
To: Steph from Stillwater
I think that Bud will find his dad but I don't think that Herman is his dad I think that he is another relative.
From:
will
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: alicia John T. Tuck Elementary
I also think this book is great. Do you think Bud will see Deza again? I'll I'll write to you daily ,if you'll write back.
From:
Someone
Grade 6
Sheridan Elementary
Petoskey, MI
To: Superman
I think that you should turn you self in so that we can go onto book club. It is not fair that we have to suffer.
From:
Amanda
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: anyone who is nice!
I think that bud made a smart desion by going with that guy "vampire." What do you think???

-Amanda

From:
Amanda
Grade 6
Stillwater Elementary
Newton, NJ
To: Anyone
Does any one think that Bud will not find his father?