Bud, Not Buddy by Christopher Paul Curtis Wednesday, February 13 If you submitted a comment about Bud, Not Buddy on February 13, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links: January  22 23 24 25  28 29 30 31  February  1 4 5 6 7 8 11  12 13 14 15

 

From: Kelsey Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Sabrina I agree that I would like to know why Todd stuck the pencil up Bud's nose, but I think he did it because he didn't want a stranger in his home.
From: chris Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	I think herman calloway is to old to be bud's dad
From: hobie wanamaker Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: anybody who wants to read mine i think that the sandwich that lefty lewis gave bud is better with the mustard than without the mustard. even though bud ate it anyway with the mustard.
From: Kelsey Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: anyone and everyone Why do you people think that Herman Callaway is Bud's dad.
From: hobie Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	does any body think that Herman E calloway is buds father, i sure do because well why do you think that h has all those fliers
From: hobie Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	does any body think that Herman E calloway is buds father, i sure do because well why do you think that h has all those fliers
From: kelsey Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: earthlings On a scale from 1 - 10 what would you rate Bud, not Buddy so far?
From: kelsey Grade 6 Barrington Elementary Upper Arlington, OH	To: Chris What are you saying no to Hobie for?
From: hobie Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	i would have to say that bud not buddy from 1-10 is a 5 because the book has not really been exciting. all he has been doing so far is just looking for his father.
From: Antonella Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	I would rate this book a 1.
From: Jill Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Anyone I think that H.E.C is Bud,s grandpa or something like that. He seems too old to be his dad. Does anybody agree with me?
From: Kayla Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Anyone who wants to read this! I think Herman E. Calloway is One of Buds relitives and they will live there together.Also I think Herman E. Calloway will share lots of memeries with bud and find they have a lot of things to talk about.
From: Jill Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Somebody cool I really like the book because its kind of interesting because I didn't know that much about this time period and what it was like to live back then. I also like how the author uses phrases such as ...cool as a cucumber, or He who laughs last laughs best.What do you think?
From: Kiera Grade 6 Barrington Elementary Upper Arlington, OH	To: anyone I think that Herman E calloway isn't his father and that one of the other guys might be his father that Herman E Calloway is related to him but not his father
From: Carmen	To: Everyone Hi! Thanks for your comments today! Just a little bit of advice: When you reply, try to give more than a one-word answer. That way it's easier for all of us to understand what you are saying and who you are responding to. Thank you.
From: Raoul	To: Everyone Hi! I think it's a good idea to talk about why we like or don't like the book. Let's share our opinions and back them up with solid details from the book.
From: Toria Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Chris Chris, I think Herman E. Calloway may be old but is Bud's father. Why do you think Mr.Calloway is to old to be Bud's father?
From: Haley Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Hobie I agree with you. I think Herman E. Calloway is an alias, and he just didn't want Bud's mom to find out where he was (but I think he still misses his wife, but he doesn't know she is dead).
From: Madi Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Hobie I agree that Herman is bud's dad but he sounds like he is 50. I still think he sounds like his dad, and he talks like his dad, but Herman still sounds like he is 50.
From: Shelby Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kelsy People think Herman E. Calloway is his father bacause they are very alike.
From: Cole Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	I think Herman E. Calloway is Bud's father becuase their last names are alike with the "Cal."
From: clint Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: chris i agree, chris i think he is to old. i'm in mrs.harris's 4th grade at horizon.i disagree with hobi.
From: Kimberly Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kiera I think Herman E. Calloway might be Bud's grandad.
From: Mary Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Hobie I think "H.E.C." is Bud's dad.
From: Trip Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	I think bud's father is really Jimmy, and his grandfather is Herman E. Calaway. Does anybody else think so?
From: Caitlin Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Hobie Dear Hobie, I would rate the book a 7 or 8. I think Mr. Herman E. Callaway is Bud's relative or long lost father. I think this because he is so shocked that Bud has come to find him.
From: mary hannah Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Hobie Dear Hobie, I would rate it a 7 if the highest is a 10. I don't know about your teacher, but my teacher, Mr.Hill, makes it interesting. Mary Hannah
From: Alex Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kelsey I would rate this book 10. It is exciting,descriptive,and interesting . I want to finish to know the ending.
From: J.D. Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	Do you think Herman E. Calloway is Bud's dad? I tink he is.
From: Stephanie Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kelsey Bud,Not Buddy would be rated a 6.I really like the first chapter!The book is pretty cool!What do you think?
From: Becky Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kelsey I would rate it a 7. It's not the best book I ever read, but it is fantastic to read!
From: Adam Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: Kelsey I would give it a 9 because it is one of my favorite books. What would you give it?
From: Jessica Grade 4th Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: To anyone who wants to read this: Do you really think Herman E. Calloway is Bud's father?I do,but I don't because he seems to old. He just doesn't look like he could be his dad,but in some way he does. Sincerely, Jessica
From: Nonie Grade 4 Horizon Elementary Madison, WI	To: anyone who wants to read this message Do you think Lefty Lewis really is a crimnal? I kind of do because he is hiding something from the police. I wonder if this will efect the story?
From: Michael G Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Kelsey i'd rate it a 8 or a 9
From: Andrew Grade 6th Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: To Doug and Mike Hey wuts your favirte part in the book guys
From: Doug Grade 6th Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Anybody So far the book is good but somewhat boring because Bud's Just looking for his father which is totally boring, but besides that its a pretty exiting book
From: Doug Grade 6th Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Andrew i think the best part in the book is when he missed the train hah nothing else is that exiting
From: Michael G Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Hobie I think it's cool that Bud is H.E.C. son because HEC is a musician
From: Doug Grade 6th Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Anybody Hey everybody, Whats up? nothin much here. How do you people like the book? write me back and tell me what you think about it
From: Mike G Grade 6 Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Andrew + Doug i think that the best part is when Buds fake dad said that he went to the potty.
From: Andrew Grade 6th Stillwater Elementary Newton, NJ	To: Mike,Hobie,doug,and other bud people I think I like this book not really peace out
From: Mike G Grade 6 Barrington Elementary Upper Arlington, OH	To: anybody i think the book is good how about you write back please