Student Comments About Maniac Magee

Friday, January 23

If you submitted a comment about Maniac Magee by 5:00 p.m. EST on January 23, it should appear below. If you want to view comments for another day, use these links:

January   20   21   22   23   26   27   28   29   30

February   2   3   4


JANUARY 23, 1998
FROM:
Ronald L.
Grade 5
P.S.133Q
Bellerose, NY
MESSAGE:
To Monica T.
I like this book too. I wouldn't like being chased by a bully either. It would be scary! I think I'd faint.

FROM:
Ryan L.
Grade 5
P.S.133Q
Bellerose, NY
MESSAGE:
Reply to: Xinchen
I would feel wierd if I was in Amanda Beale's house.It would try to feel like home because I never had a permanent home for so long. Do you think Mars Bars is going to be friends with Maniac?

FROM:
Keishia B.
Grade 5
Landis Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
Hey Hollie this is Keishia.I also find it very odd that he's alergic to pizza.I feel sorry for him because I love Pizz,and eat it all the time.I'me also glad that Mrs.Beal is letting him stay.I also think it's cool that he stood up in church,and yelled HALLELUJAH and A-MEN.He realy fit's in there don't you think?I think this book is getting realy good.How about you?

Gotta go,bye.Oh yeah write back!


FROM:
Chaz
Grade 3
Rees Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
I think that Amanda was mad at Maniac when he wanted to leave because she really liked him and maybe she even thought of him as a brother. I think that he will go to live at the zoo. Some of my friends think that he will go back to live in the house where his mother and father lived before they died.

(Sam and Eric have responded to this message.)


FROM:
Keishia B.
Grade 5
Landis Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
Hey Mike this is Keishia.I can't say I agree with you on you're response. Because I've read on,and beileve me he has'nt gone back yet.

Gotta go,bye!


FROM:
Drashaud P.
Grade 5
Landis Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
Overall I think that Manic is not crazy or an maniac I think that he is just confused.I think that is other people opion that he is an maniac.Well N-E WAYZ I think that he is a very nice person.I was descusing with my reading group and my friend named Brennon said he is mentaly challened. No Brennon we all said at the same time. Then I said woudn't you be the same way if your panrents died, and you were an orphan at the age of 2 years old and you lived in an pig pen.Well gotta go.

FROM:
Keishia B.
Grade 5
Landis Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
Hey Dustin this is Keishia.He did run that long,because he's in another place.That's real far away.The only way he got there is by running.He must be in shape.Don't you think?In the book it said he'd been running almost a year.

Gotta go,bye!


FROM:
Manetria J.
Grade 5
Landis Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
Today is my first day because of my absent.I think that Maniac Magee is a very good book so far .It was rude of Jeffrey to go into that womens house and eat. It was nice of Mr. and Mrs.Beale to let Jeffrey stay there with them.It was nice of Jeffrey to keep house clean and taking a bath with the kids and keep them from coloring everything in site.Do you think Jeffrey's aunt and uncle will find them? I think it was rude of that man to put FISHBELLY GO HOME on the house just because he was white.What do you do you think?

Ariana Yes they are going to let him stay for dinner better yet they let him stay for ever he keeps the kids from coloring every thing in site and Mrs.Beale dosen't have to clean up as much.Please wriye back.


FROM:
Alicia K.
Grade 6
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
Dear Robbie,
I think he was called Maniac because he was weird . I think Amanda was really nice to let him stay stay with her. I'd probably wouldn't want to let him stay if I was black because he was white. I know that is prejudice, but back then people didn't think that was bad. I know they didn't have a lot of books back then, but reading the encyclopedia is the the most boringest book ever made.

(Brennon has responded to this message.)


FROM:
Adam P.
Grade 5
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
For: Israel L.
My favorite part of the book is when Magee first came to Two Mills. What is yours? I think that Magee realy likes Amanda. Do you?

Well got to go. Bye

(Israel has responded to this message.)


FROM:
Jill P.
Grade 5
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
I think Maniac Magee shouldn't have left the Beales. They wanted him to stay, and they didn't care about the prejudiced people. They wanted him to stay with them, and I think he should have.

FROM:
Hollie F.
Grade 5
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
Keishia B
I love pizza too! If I couldn't eat pizza I would die. Do you have e-mail at your house?

Well gotta go!
Bye!!!

(Keishia has responded to this message.)


FROM:
Sam K.
Grade 5
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
Hey Chaz
I also think Amanda is mad at Maniac Magee. I also think Amanda and Maniac Magee consider each other brother and sister. I think you're right about Maniac moving to the zoo. Please write back soon.

(Steven has responded to this message.)


FROM:
Eric S.
Grade 5
Barringer Road Elementary
Ilion, NY
MESSAGE:
Hey Chaz
I also think Amanda is mad at Maniac Magee. What do you think will happen next in the story? Please answer back soon.

(Steven has responded to this message.)


FROM:
Michael
Grade 3
Rees Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
I think Maniac was very kind to leave the Beales' so they won't get hurt. I think that it was really cool that he untied the big knot. Jeffrey might have gotten the nickname Maniac because he did crazy stuff. It was really nice of Maniac to take baths with Hester and Lester.

FROM:
Nnenna
Grade 3
Rees Elementary
Houston, TX
MESSAGE:
We think it's really wierd that Manic is allergic to pizza. Do you know anyone who is allergic to pizza?Where do you think he slept?

(Manetria has responded to this message.)