Student Comments About The View from Saturday

Friday, December 18

If you submitted a comment about The View from Saturday by 5:00 p.m. EST on December 18, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:

December   1   2   3   4   7   8   9   10   11   14   15   16   17   18
DECEMBER 18, 1998
FROM:
Lindsay F.
Grade 6
JFK Middle School
Port Jefferson Station, NY 		MESSAGE:
Stephine and Aron I think that Julian did the right thing because Giger would have gotten sick from the tranqlizer. If he didn't remove the biscuts the other dog would have gotten sick too. So thats why I think Julian did the right thing and I don't think that Hamilton Knapp did the right thing.
FROM:
Elyssa P.
Grade 6
JFK Middle School
Port Jefferson Station, NY 		MESSAGE:
The View From Saturday was a wonderful book. I think it is amazing how E.L. Konigsburg set the story up. It really touched me when the Souls wanted to get Mrs. Oloinski to stand up on her own feet and they did. When everyone held out an arm or leg when Mrs. Olinski made Ham and Jared go to the board, that was standing up. Also when she got held up in her wheelchair. The ending of the story was alright, it could of been better though. I think it was nice how Mr. Singh and Mrs. Olinski got along so perfectly and Mr. Singh knew Mrs. Olinsky and what she was thinking so well. They had a great relashionship, just like the legendary Souls did!