Archive: October 15-17, 1997 |
|
|
|
|
| View comments for: |
Wednesday, October 15
Thursday, October 16 Friday, October 17 |
|
OCTOBER 15, 1997 |
|
|
FROM: Cheetara Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Do you think that Judd has a right to beat Shiloh? How do you think Marty would get proof to keep Shiloh? Why do you think Shiloh is being beating? Do you think Shiloh had the right to runaway? Why? How would Marty feel if Shiloh got hurt? (Paul, Dylan, Cory, Amanda, Philippe, Vanessa, and Sarah, have answered these questions.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Liz Grube Managing Editor Small Planet Communications |
MESSAGE:
Those are some great questions, Cheetara. Are there any other students out there who have some answers or opinions? If so, write back! |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Anh D. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I feel sorry for Shiloh. I was surprie when Judd kicked Shiloh in front of Marty and his dad. How would you feel if you were Shiloh? (Becca has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tyrone W. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think shiloh is very smart do you? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Hussein A. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think Shiloh likes Marty because Marty has been taken good care of Shiloh. Shiloh doesn't like Judd because Judd hasen't treated Shiloh right. Marty thinks Judd is going to kill Shiloh. So thats why Marty is looking after Shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Bridney M. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty likes Shiloh as a pet dog. His father thinks He's a pest. He's a nice dog but still he should'nt be misstreated. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Diane Lindbert Grade 4 teacher Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
This message is for all of the students (Cheetara, Anh, Tyrone, Hussein, and Bridey) from Klentzman Intermediate who posted comments on Wednesday. My class will begin Shiloh tomorrow and will be posting messages too! I was so excited tonight to see children all the way from the great state of Texas participating. You all have really good questions and comments. I do think Shiloh is a very smart dog because he is hanging around Marty who is a very good person. If I were Shiloh, I would have run away too. Talk to you on Thursday!!!! |
|
OCTOBER 16, 1997 |
|
|
FROM: Anusha A. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
My group and I thought that chapters 3 and 4 of Shiloh was really interesting. We thought that Judd might really be mistreating Shilo and that Marty should return Shiloh but then again he should not. What do you think? (This is an answer to Cortney's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Vanessa M. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty is happy about Shiloh coming back and that he's not giving Shiloh back to judd even if he promised. The only way Judd can get to Shiloh is through Marty. I also think that Judd did shoot that beagle in the head (This is an answer to Jennifer's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nicole Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
We are surprised that Marty is actully trying to keep Shiloh! Why do you think Shiloh is still shaking? Why do you think Judd is so rude? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Cortney E. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Do you really think Judd was going to beat Shiloh? I do because Judd looks like he's really mean to his dogs. Well don't take my word for it read the book and email to me what you think. (Anusha has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Dylan R. Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think that shiloh is really smart. I think that shiloh has a right to run away. (These are answers to Tyrone's and Cheetara's questions. Philippe has also commented on this issue.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Amreen Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
My group thinks that Marty is a good person because he likes taking care of animals instead of hurtinn them. We also talked about that if a dog folloed you home what would you do with it? I said that I would keep it and take care of it. What would you do with the dog? (Aleshia has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Allysha Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Do you think Marty feels strongly for Shiloh because he thinks that Judd might hurt Shiloh again. Do you think Marty is the right person for Shiloh? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Kermecia Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I thought that it was kind of sad and kind of happy. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Zohar Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
We talk about Mr. Judd treating Shiloh, and how marty will get Shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jennifer H. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Were confued about if Judd kill the dog or not? Did Judd shoot the dog in the street? If Shiloh saw Marty get hurt what do you think Shiloh Would do? (Vanessa has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Vernatta B. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
If you were Shiloh what would you do? Judd doesn't feed Shiloh when he's hungry! (Cory has answered this question.) |
|
OCTOBER 17, 1997 |
|
|
FROM: Erin Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I noticed from the begining that there is a Verginia Dilect. If I were Shiloh I would trust Marty to take care of me. Would you? Do you think Judd was telling the truth when he told Marty's father that Shiloh was his? I think Marty is caring for animals. Marty is a nice person. (This is an answer to Matthew's question -- see below.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think that Judd is a lier. Do you think that Judd is a lier? I think that Marty is very nice, do you? (Erin has answered this question -- see above. Ryan has also answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Paul R. Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty will help Shiloh by keeping him secretly and hiding him from Judd. How do you think Marty will help Shiloh? Cheetara, I think Shiloh is being beatin becouse Judd sed he would give him a woliping if he ran away agan. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Christy Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Do you think Marty is a honest person? I feel sorry for Judd when he was a little boy how do you feel ? I think some one will find out Marty's keeping Shiloh what do you think ? (Datrian, Sheneka, Anh, and Ryan have answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Bryan Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think that Marty and his frind will make a little shed. And will keep Shiloh in the shed intill he is beter. (This is an answer to Paul's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Sheneka T. Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Is Marty is an honest person I think that Marty is telling the truth because he just want Shiloh safe with him and not with Judd because Judd is calling Shiloh names and kicking him around and Judd is not wanting to feed Shiloh at all the times. (This is an answer to Christy's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tara Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Jud should not abuse Shiloh. I also think Shiloh is very smart for running away. What do you think? (This is an answer to Tyrone's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tehreem Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
When shiloh went to Marty, Judd hit him, and told him never to go back to him. Why does Judd want Shiloh when he has alot of other dogs? (Lindsey has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Diron Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
In chapters 5 and 6 what do you think will happen when Judd find's out Marty's keeping Shiloh from him . I think Judd will tell Marty's dad to whoop him. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Datrian Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty is not an honest person and I do think he's an honest person because he is not telling the truth. The reason why I dont think he's an honest person is because he lies when his parent's ask about Shiloh. He is honest because he keeps Shiloh from being hurt. (This is an answer to Christy's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Michael Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
Yes I do think that Marty will try to help Shiloh. I think he will build a house or somthing like that (This is an answer to Paul's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jason Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Shiloh has the right to run away because Judd shuldn't kick Shiloh. I think this book is a good book. Do you? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Cory Grade 4 Cornell Elementary Okemos, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Shilo had a right to run away. Judd is doing animal abuse. He should goto court. If i were Shilo i would've ran away too. (These are answers to Cheetara and Vernatta's questions.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Amanda Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
We think Judd should not beat on Shiloh because Shiloh is a dog that needs a good home and even though Judd was beaten all his life dosen't mean that he has to beart on Shiloh just for running away. What would you think about Judd beating on Shiloh ? (This is an answer to Cheetara's question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Aleshia Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Amreen we like your question. we said that we would put up a sign that say we found a lost dog if it is yours call- [281] - 324-3628. Thank you. we think that Shiloh found a nice owner. do you think Shiloh found a nice owner. If so, tell us . |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Eloisa Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Marty's lies are growing alot We think that Marty might keep lieing till he has enough money to buy Shiloh. Till when do you think he'll stop lieing? Why? (Tambra has answered this question.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Pierre Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
(Pierre, you filled out a form but there was no message. Write again if you have some comments!) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Samir Grade 5 Klentzman Intermediate AISD Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
My group talked about Shiloh. We thought Marty's secret is getting bigger and bigger and bigger. We even tought that when Marty told the lies because he dont want no one to know he had Shiloh. What do you think? |
|
|
|