Tuesday, October 6
If you're ready to submit a comment or question now, click here. |
|
|
OCTOBER 6, 1998 |
|
|
FROM: Ryan Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty nad Dara Lynn both hate Judd Travers. Marty and Dara Lynn both feel bad for Shiloh.
Marty fights for Siloh.
|
|
|
|
|
FROM: Allison Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Dara lynn and marty are diffrent because,marty is older and dara lynn is kind of a tatail tale and marty is not.I think that Dara lynn and marty are simmlar because they both fell bad for shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Corrine Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think they are different because Dara Lynn is seven and Marty is eleven. I think they are simmalar because they both love Shiloh and they play with their food a lot. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Alex W. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is sensitive about eating and killing animals and Dara Lynn isn`t bothered by eating animals that that have been killed. Both Dara Lynn and Marty feel sorry for Shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Crystal Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty and Dara Lynn both care for Shiloh but Marty cares more. Sometimes the girls only get there way. Why didn't the dad beleve Marty when he said,"Judd is herting Shiloh? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Lauren Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is braver than Dara Lynn because Marty gave Shiloh some food when he wasn't supposed to and Dara Lynn didn't. They both play with their food. They both feel sorry for Shiloh. They both wondered what the dog would eat. What was your favorite chapter 1 and chapter 2? Are you enjoying Shiloh so far? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jon K. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Dara Lynn and Marty are similar because they both fell the same about the dog. There are many differences like Dara lynn is younger then her brother. Dara Lynn and becky get what they wont more then Marty sometimes. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nikita E. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
There are a few ways Dara Lynn is different from Marty.Marty is eleven and Dara Lynn is seven .Marty doesn't like to talk about killing animals and Dara Lynn does.There are ways they are similar.They both play with there food.They both feel sorry for Shiloh! |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew B. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty is mad and sad. Marty does't want judd to get shiloh. He will do anything to get shiloh back and does't want to leave shiloh. Marty wants to buy shiloh so shiloh does not get hit by judd. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Lauren Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Dara Lynn gets more out of her parents and he can't get anything out of them. They both want to keep and feed the dog. I just didn't know why he kicked the dog just because Shiloh ran away if my dog ran away I'd be happy that someone found him. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Richard Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Dara Lynn is seven and Marty is eleven. Dara lynn likes to dip her bread in tea and Marty doesn't like to.Dara likes to know about how Marty's Dad kills there food.Dara Lynn was from a differnt family but now she is part of theirs.Marty likes to shoot stuff with his rifle. Theuy both like animals. Dara Lynn wants to keep Shiloh too. Marty has a 22 rifle. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Corrine Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
to Megan: I think the book is kind of sad because Shiloh is abused because he gets kicked a lot because he's not a good dog when he's hunting because he always runs away. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Toni Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
She pushes up her beans and he doesn't.The did not see the dog first.They both feel sorry for the dog.What do you think about Judd? Do you think Judd beats the dog? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: April E. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
To Bobby P. I like the part when Shiloh followed Marty home. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Amanda Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think the differnces beteen Marty and Dara are Marty is braver than Dara Lynn because at the dinner table Dara Lynn didn't keep bugging about Shiloh and Marty did.I think they are similar also.One similarity that I think they have in common is that they both love dogs.Those are the main differnces and similarity that I can find.
OH,I almost forgot about my question
|
|
|
|
|
FROM: Lauren F., Crystal, and Lauren S. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
To Megan: We thought your questions were interesting. We like the book so far because the author explains it really well. She doesn't just tell you something and then go to a different subject. She explains it well. We were wondering how you like the book. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jack Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
One similarity is they are in the same family. Marty and Dara Lynn ply with their food at dinner. Marty likes to shoot cans off of a fence. Dara Lynn is 7 and Marty is 11. Marty found Shiloh and Dara Lynn didn't. If Marty gets to keep Shiloh where is he going to keep him??? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nick Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty and Dara are different in these ways, Dara is more of a gory person. And Marty is more kind hearted then Dara. Marty and Dara arn't that similar but there are some similar things like they both like dogs. Another thing is they both can be kind some point. Dara isn't always that nice, as I explained in my first paragraph. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nikita E. & Jon K. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
TO Megan #1We like when Marty found Shiloh.#2We are going on chapter 3. #3Are favorite chater was Shiloh because he was quite. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Andrew Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is more caring than her plus she doesn't like animals.And she rabbit meat and he doesn't.She does want to take Shiolh back.Marty is a normal kind of kid.Marty gets |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew W. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
DIFFERENT Dara Lynn likes the killing of animals and likes to talk about it on the other side Marty doesn't have the slightest wish for it or to talk about it. They have different opinions about different stuff when they talk about different stuff. They are different ages.
Similar
|
|
|
|
|
FROM: Rohan S. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty and Dara Linn are different because Marty is older than Dara Linn and Dara is younger than Marty.Another difference between Marty and Dara Linn is that Marty does not get away away with things. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Zachary B. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Dara and Marty are different in some ways... 1. Marty has a passion for dogs and Dara only cares so so. 2. Marty plays with his food and Dara does not.
Dara and Marty are the same becouse...
|
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tricia Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is different from Dara Lynn because Marty wanted to know if the rabbit died right away (He didn't want the rabbit to feel pain).Dara Lynn wants to know if her dad shot its head of(She was thinking bad thoughts). Marty is like Dara Lynn because they both play with their food. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Karrington G. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
To Megan D. 1. The part I like about the book is when Shiloh runs home to Marty. 2. I am on chapter 5 3. My favorite caracter is Shiloh. 4.Yes I am new to the internet. 5. Yes I am in a group. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tiffany S. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Dear Marcelo D. I think that Shiloh should be with Marty, not Judd Travers. Judd Travers is mean. If I was Marty, I would not give the dog back to Judd. Would you have done that? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Gabi Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty likes Dara. Marty likes Cheerios and she doesn't. Dara doesn't have a mom or dad and Marty does. They both live in West Virginia I wonder if Marty gets to keep Shiloh? (Zack has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Grant Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is older than Dara Lynn. Marty is a boy and Dara Lynn is girl. Marty pours Cheerios for Lynn. Lynn doesn't pour Cheerios. They're both in the same family. They both feel sorry for Shiloh. They both want Shiloh back. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Erica Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
I have a couple questions for you.Do you think Judd hurts Shiloh? Do you think Shiloh will run away? How? How do you think Marty's parents feel about Marty's relationship with Shiloh? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Allen B. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Do you think Shiloh will run away?Why? Do you think Judd will find out Shiloh is missing? How? Why is Judd so mean? (David has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Alexa Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Hi! Marty cares about Shiloh . How did Martys parents feel about Martys realaship with the dog? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: James C. Grade 3 Rees Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
We thought that it was sad when Marty's father didn't think that he could go to veterinary school. We liked the author's words: "My dream sort of leaks out like water in a paper bag." Those words really give us a picture in our heads. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Toni Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think Judd is too mean to the dog and should not even have a dog. Judd should not even have the rightto hunt. Do you think he shoud have a right to have a dog? Do you think Marty is doing the right thing? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Marisol D. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
In chapter 2, I think that when Marty returned Shiloh back to Jud he felt very sad. How do you think Marty felt when he returned Shiloh? (Maritza has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Maritza M. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think that Shiloh didn't want to go with Jud because he treated him very bad. How do you think Shiloh felt when he returned back with Jud? (Marisol has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Emily, Jenny, Joradn, Kevin, Ashley Grade 4 Mother of Good Counsel Milwaukee, WI |
MESSAGE:
Judd's words and actions reveal that he is a bad man. He lies and is mean to animals. Our group doesn't really like Judd. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Megan, Gina, Tom, Wayne Grade 4 Mother of Good Counsel Milwaukee, WI |
MESSAGE:
We think the book is really go so far. I hope Marty can keep Shiloh. Whay would Judd want to shoot deer out of season? Why do you think Judd is so meant to his dogs? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tierney, Eric, Ronisha, Emilio Grade 4 Mother of Good Counsel Milwaukee, WI |
MESSAGE:
We think the book is good so far. We want to know why Judd is so mean to his dogs? We think he is mean, but aren't sure why. We think Shiloh is cool. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Robert, Julia, Mike, Teresa, Nikki Grade 4 Mother of Good Counsel Milwaukee, WI |
MESSAGE:
How come Judd abuses his dogs? We think Judd is a mean person. The book is really good so far. Why do you think Judd disobeys the law? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Merari, Sara, Ryan, Meghan, Teddy Grade 4 Mother of Good Counsel Milwaukee, WI |
|