Wednesday, October 7
If you're ready to submit a comment or question now, click here. |
|
|
OCTOBER 7, 1998 |
|
|
FROM: Jessica D. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Marty keeps telling more lies so he can feed and take care of Shiloh. Why did Judd kick Shiloh when he saw him? (David has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tiffany S. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
No, Marty does not feel sorry for Judd, I don't even feel sorry for Judd because of what he does to Shiloh. It is wrong to abuse the dog, but it is Judd's dog. I would try to get the dog because when my dog is loose, I go get him. I do not let him run like Judd does. What would you do? (Katie, Tj, Betty, and Kyle have responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Maritza M. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Marisol, I think that Marty felt very sad and sorry for Shiloh because Jud is going to treat hem very bad and Shiloh's life is going to terrible with Jud. Jud is going to be very mean to Shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew B. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Judd said, "Once I find the dog, I will break his legs." Marty is scared that Judd is going to get mad at Shiloh. Do you think Judd will find the dog? I think he won't because he won't go up into the woods. (Gabi has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Duwayne B. Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
I liked the book Shiloh becauc it talck abhout a dog bing abused by a boy named Judd and a boy named Marty |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Michael Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
marty is a honest person because he loves shiloh and he loves his mom and his dad and shiloh loves marty |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Brittney Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
Marty feels sorry for Judd because Judd only got to go hunting with his dad.I also feel sorry for Judd because the same thing as Marty.I feel sorry for Judd because only going hunting would get boring after a while.My class named Judd Mudd because he is mean to people and his animals.Shiloh is a good book.I like to read.Marty is only half honest because he lied alot about Shiloh.Marty's secret is growing because more and more people know where Shiloh is.Marty keeps telling more lies because he does not want anyone to know about Shiloh and where he is at. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Marisol D. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Maritza M.,I think that Shiloh felt sad when he returned with Jud because he was scared to be kicked him again. I think that when Shiloh came to marty he felt happy. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: David M. Grade 4 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Allen B., I think Shiloh will run away from Judd because he doesn't like him. I think Judd will find out that Shiloh is missing because if Judd gives him food and he'll find out. Marty sometimes has nightmares about Shiloh out in the rain feeling disappointed at him.I wonder why when Marty sees bugs it reminds him of Shiloh? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Karrington G. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
How is Marty's secret growing? I think that Marty's secret is growing because Marty keeps on lying to everyone because he doesn't want to give up the dog. Can someone else tell me why Marty's secret is growing? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Katie Y. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Marty is not honest because he keeps telling lies to people. (April has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Kyle B. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Marty has to keep lying because if he wants to protect Shiloh,he would be better off lying. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Betty K. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Martys secret is shiloh. And his secret is growing because whenever Judd asks if he saw shiloh he says no. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tj J. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Marty does not feel sorry for Judd.Neither do I because he kicks his dog and he's not lawbiting. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Katie, Tj, Betty, Kyle Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Tiffany. We would post up signs and offer an award and I would also go and look for him. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Dhymond N. Grade 4 Alexander Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think Marty really cared aboat Shiloh beacause he even wanted to buy the dog from Judd Travers When he got Shiloh for his own dog Shiloh really touched his heart because when he first saw Shiloh he acted like he knew the dog and when he stole Shilh he fed him twice a day and let Shiloh lick all over his face. Why would Marty act like the dog was his when he did not know the dog? What ave you the interest to write this book? Do you write other books? Did you think about giving Shiloh a last name? How about Shiloh Preston. |
|
|
|