Thursday, October 8
If you're ready to submit a comment or question now, click here. |
|
|
OCTOBER 8, 1998 |
|
|
FROM: Gabi Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Matthew B. I think he'll find out. What about you? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Toni Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I think he will find the dog or maybe his dad might find him or his sister might find the dog or maybe a wild dog might get him. Do you think a wild animal will get it? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Ryan Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
#1What is your favorite part in the story so far? #2Do you think that Marty will get Shiloh? #3If Marty gets Shiloh where do tou think he will get the food and money for the food? #4 If Judd Travers gets caught abusing his dogs what do you think will hapen to him? #5Do you think that Judd Travers is mean to his dogs or do you tink that he is is treating his dogs right? #6When you get to the end of the book do you think that Marty will get Shiloh? (Jordan, Justin, and Tiffany have responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nick Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
1# Do you like Judd at all?! I sort of do because he is just trying to trane his dogs. But it is in the wrong. Why? 2# Why do you like siloh, and why? (April has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Zack B. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
To Gabi S.: Yes,I think that he will get to keep Shiloh. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Allison Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I have a few questions. 1#Do you think Judd will ever be nice? 2#Do you think that Marty can keep Shiloh a secret? 3#why?4#why not? 4#Why do you think Judd is so mean? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jessica D. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Marty keeps on telling that his secret is like a time bomb waiting to go off because he keeps on trying to get food for shiloh and his mother watches him every minute at the dinner table. His mother is going to catch him one day. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Amanda Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Karrington, I think Marty's secret is growing because he promised Judd that he would bring Shiloh back if he saw him. Marty hates Judd so much he will never give Shiloh back. He has to keep it from everyone else so they don't take Shiloh back. (Laura, Tiffany, C.J., Andy, Harrison, Crystal, Jan, Dhymond, and Samiha have responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nikita E. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
I have some questions to ask you. What do you think of Marty? Do you like the book? Why? What chapter and page are you on? (Stephanie has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Grant Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty is unlike his parents because he won't give back Jud's dog. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Karringon G. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Marty says that his secret about Shiloh is like a time bomb waiting to go off. What do think he means. I think that he means that judd is going to fine shiloh. What do you think it means? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Karlee Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Marty love Shiloh very much that when Judd goes hunting and Shiolh splits up with the rest of the dog. Marty gets Shiloh and he makes a cage for Shiloh and he is going to keep him. Now Marty can sleep now and he sleep through the night and he felt much better the next morning. Judd is very mean to his dogs some times he killed one of his dogs. He kicks shiloh and the others too. Marty think that Judd killed the dog that he lied about the dog getting shot in the head. How old do you think Shiloh is? Did all of the story happen for real life? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew W. Grade 4 Murphy Elementary Haslett, MI |
MESSAGE:
Where is Marty going to get the moeny to buy Shiloh back from Judd Travers. How do you think hes going to get Shiloh back. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nettie F. Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
Hi Im Nettie, Our class just got done reading SHILOH, did yours? I thought that it was a really good book, I liked when Judd went whooo. What part did you like? (Nicole has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Marisol D. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
I think that when Marty lied to his dad and Jud he felt bad bicause he never lies. How do you think that Marty felt when he lied to his father and Judd? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Maritza M. Grade 5 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
Karrington G., I think that Marty is a good boy and when he lies he feels very bad. He is lying because how you sed he wants to protect Shiloh and he wants to take care of Shiloh and the lies that he tells are why lies to protect Shiloh.I wander if some one is going to descover Marty with Shiloh and he will have to give Shiloh to Judd. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Cierria Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
Hi I just got done with SHILOH it was very interesting to read.I hope I can watch the movie in class sometime, or in A movietheater with my family dering summer. (Jaime has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tiffany Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
HI MY NAME IS TIFFANY AND I JUST FINSH SHILOH IT WAS VERY INTERESTING TO READ.AND I HOPE ICAN GET MORE INFORMATION BECAUSE IT WAS A VERY GOOD BOOK AND I LIKE SHERRODSVILLE. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: David M. Grade 4 Landis Elementary Houston, TX |
MESSAGE:
JESSICA D., I think Judd is kicking Shiloh because he's angry at him. I also think Judd is kicking Shiloh because like he's a hunter he treats animals bad. Marty found a way to hide Shiloh from Judd.Marty and his family were eatingand felt something suspecios.Martys dad was telling Judd if he keeps hunting he's going to jail. I think Judd was praying what to do with Shiloh.If I was Marty I'd return Shiloh because he swore to Judd that he would return him if hr saw him (Jessica has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Kyle Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
Hi my name is KYLE. I like the part when Marty worked to get Shiloh,whats your favorit part. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Aerial M. and Jeanna Grade 4 Sherrodsville Elementary Sherrodsville, OH |
MESSAGE:
Shiloh is a good book to read.I like chapter 1 because it talks alot about SHILOH.And it talks alot about Marty.And Marty's family. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jessica D. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
To Duwayne: Well, you are right. Marty does not like the dog getting abused. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Matthew B. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Ma found out that Marty has kept the dog. Now I think Judd is going to find out. (Zach has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: April E. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
To Katie Y. I think Marty lies alot . He is not honest. But it's for Shiloh's own good. I would do the same. Would you. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tiffany S. Grade 5 Adams School Scranton, PA |
MESSAGE:
Dear Duwayne B. Marty is not abusing the dog, Judd is the only person abusing the dog. Marty cares for the dog. Judd is the one who does like and doesn't like Shiloh. This sounds weird, but it is true. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nicole Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Nettie- How did you like Shiloh? What part did you like best? Did you see the movie? It was great!! |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jaime S. Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Cierria- Hi! I also like Shiloh, but we didn't finish it yet. I have only seen half of the movie, but I found it better than the book. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Nicole Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Nettie- I loved the Movie ,how about you? We haven't finished yet. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Jordan, Justin Grade 4 Middlebrook Elementary Trumbull, CT |
MESSAGE:
Ryan #1My favorite part of the book so far is when Marty found the Dog on a bridge. #2Yes because his owner does not treat him well and Marty is working hard for him. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Courtney and Katie Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
Marty thinks that time is going to run out.And he thinks everyone will find out especially his parents. We think Martys parents will make him take Shiloh back to Judd Travers. What will Judd do to Marty if he finds out Marty was hiding Shiloh? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Chelsey and Karen Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
We think "waiting for a time bomb" means that pretty soon somebody will find out about Shiloh. What do you think Marty will do if someone finds out? |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Andrew and Cody Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
What do you think is going to happen to Marty now that his mom has found out? How do you think Marty is going to save Shiloh now that his mom found out? Explain. |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Tyrel and Max Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
What do you think will happen since Marty's mom discovered his secret? We think the Friendly is a caring community.
|
|
|
|
|
FROM: Brian and Tanner Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
David's family is rich and have a big house Marty's family is poor and doesn't have a big house. (Eamonn has responded to this message.) |
|
|
|
|
FROM: Marcus Grade 5 Flandreau Middle School Flandreau, SD |
MESSAGE:
Marty's family is kind of poor. They can't afford a dog. David's mom and dad are kind of rich. Would you like David Howard for a friend? |
|
|
|