Readers' Comments

Shiloh
by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Monday, December 3
If you submitted a comment about Shiloh on December 3, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:

November 26 27 28 29 30
December 3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21

From:
Haris
Grade 5
C.L.K. Elementary
Calumet, MI To: everyone
The last chapter I'd read was chapter 8. At the end of the chapter Marty's mom finds out that Marty has Shiloh.
She saw him playing with Shiloh. I wonder what Marty's
mom will do to him? I think she will make him give
Shiloh back to Judd. I think Judd should treat his dogs
better.

From:
Holden
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Everybody
I have a question for you people.Do you think Judd cares about Git,Scram,Out and Dammit?Or do you think he only has them for hunting and showing off?I think Marty should own Judd's dogs.Do think so too?

From:
Brandon
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: everyone
Hi everyone, Shilo is a very lucky dog because Marty keeps giving him so much food and attention.
I wonder if Marty's mom will make Marty give back the dog to Judd.
Anyone who reads this comment please write back an answer.

From:
Eric
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Brandon
Brandon I agree with you completly, Judd must hate his dogs or else he wouldn't be so mean to Shiloh. I mean who else kicks his dogs, barley feeds them and tells them to git, scram and get lost. I mean, Judd Travers, Shiloh is your dog you could at least show some respect to him because you paid for him.

From:
Hannah
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Emily
I think that in the book when Judd says, "I name my dogs Git, Scram,Out and Dammit" he's referring to what he screams when they are in his way. I'm pretty sure he's trying to make a dumb joke. I wonder if something bad happend in his life that made him so miserable.

From:
Emily
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Everyone
I wonder why Judd named his dogs Git, Scram, Out and Dammit? I think that those are terrible names!! I think that he should have asked Marty for some names.
I think that Marty should be able keep Shiloh because he already has a lot of dogs and Judd doesn't treat his dogs very well.

From:
Pam
Grade 6
Marlboro Elementary
Marlboro, NJ To: Everybody
I think Shiloh will run away again. He might find Marty. Marty will put him in the hiding spot in the woods so nobody finds him. When Judd goes hunting the dogs might find him and they will give away the secret. Then Judd may hurt Shiloh and Marty because Judd will think that Marty helped Shiloh run away.
I think Judd doesn't name his dogs because if he names his dogs then somebody could call the dogs names and they can steal them. Then Judd will really be mad. Judd will probably blame it on Marty. Who knows, Marty might have taken the dogs.

From:
Samantha
Grade 6
Marlboro Elementary
Marlboro, NJ To: Kali and Kayla
I think the dog will come to Marty and his family will let Marty keep him. Shiloh will be safe. I think Judd should go to jail because he hurt all those dogs and he's mean to people.

From:
Sebastian
Grade 6
Marlboro Elementary
Marlboro, NJ To: Everybody
Hi, I think Judd should get arrested for a lot of things. First, he killed deer out of the season. Second, he spit tobacco on Marty. Third, Judd ripped off Mr. Wallace by giving him a ten instead of a twenty. Fourth, Judd was blocking Marty from seeing the tractor pull. Fifth, he should get arrested for beating his dogs for no reason.If he gets arrested Marty should get Shiloh.

From:
Robert
Grade 6
Marlboro Elementary
Marlboro, NJ To: everybody
I think that Judd Travers is mean because he beats up his dogs and tricks people. I think that Shiloh will go back to Marty's house and Marty will make a shed in the woods. There he will be safe. What do you think of Marty and Shiloh?

From:
Mrs. Samples' Class
Grade 4
Herod Elementary
Houston, TX To: Everyone
We think its good that Marty keeps the dog because since he enjoys the dog and wishes it was as good as Jesus so he could wish to keep him and his wish will come true. I also think Marty will be happier to know that Judd won't hurt Shiloh while Shiloh is with Marty.


Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Monday, December 3 If you submitted a comment about Shiloh on December 3, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:
November 26 27 28 29 30 December 3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21

From: Haris Grade 5 C.L.K. Elementary Calumet, MI	To: everyone The last chapter I'd read was chapter 8. At the end of the chapter Marty's mom finds out that Marty has Shiloh. She saw him playing with Shiloh. I wonder what Marty's mom will do to him? I think she will make him give Shiloh back to Judd. I think Judd should treat his dogs better.

From: Holden Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Everybody I have a question for you people.Do you think Judd cares about Git,Scram,Out and Dammit?Or do you think he only has them for hunting and showing off?I think Marty should own Judd's dogs.Do think so too?

From: Brandon Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: everyone Hi everyone, Shilo is a very lucky dog because Marty keeps giving him so much food and attention. I wonder if Marty's mom will make Marty give back the dog to Judd. Anyone who reads this comment please write back an answer.

From: Eric Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Brandon Brandon I agree with you completly, Judd must hate his dogs or else he wouldn't be so mean to Shiloh. I mean who else kicks his dogs, barley feeds them and tells them to git, scram and get lost. I mean, Judd Travers, Shiloh is your dog you could at least show some respect to him because you paid for him.

From: Hannah Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Emily I think that in the book when Judd says, "I name my dogs Git, Scram,Out and Dammit" he's referring to what he screams when they are in his way. I'm pretty sure he's trying to make a dumb joke. I wonder if something bad happend in his life that made him so miserable.

From: Emily Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Everyone I wonder why Judd named his dogs Git, Scram, Out and Dammit? I think that those are terrible names!! I think that he should have asked Marty for some names. I think that Marty should be able keep Shiloh because he already has a lot of dogs and Judd doesn't treat his dogs very well.

From: Pam Grade 6 Marlboro Elementary Marlboro, NJ	To: Everybody I think Shiloh will run away again. He might find Marty. Marty will put him in the hiding spot in the woods so nobody finds him. When Judd goes hunting the dogs might find him and they will give away the secret. Then Judd may hurt Shiloh and Marty because Judd will think that Marty helped Shiloh run away. I think Judd doesn't name his dogs because if he names his dogs then somebody could call the dogs names and they can steal them. Then Judd will really be mad. Judd will probably blame it on Marty. Who knows, Marty might have taken the dogs.

From: Samantha Grade 6 Marlboro Elementary Marlboro, NJ	To: Kali and Kayla I think the dog will come to Marty and his family will let Marty keep him. Shiloh will be safe. I think Judd should go to jail because he hurt all those dogs and he's mean to people.

From: Sebastian Grade 6 Marlboro Elementary Marlboro, NJ	To: Everybody Hi, I think Judd should get arrested for a lot of things. First, he killed deer out of the season. Second, he spit tobacco on Marty. Third, Judd ripped off Mr. Wallace by giving him a ten instead of a twenty. Fourth, Judd was blocking Marty from seeing the tractor pull. Fifth, he should get arrested for beating his dogs for no reason.If he gets arrested Marty should get Shiloh.

From: Robert Grade 6 Marlboro Elementary Marlboro, NJ	To: everybody I think that Judd Travers is mean because he beats up his dogs and tricks people. I think that Shiloh will go back to Marty's house and Marty will make a shed in the woods. There he will be safe. What do you think of Marty and Shiloh?

From: Mrs. Samples' Class Grade 4 Herod Elementary Houston, TX	To: Everyone We think its good that Marty keeps the dog because since he enjoys the dog and wishes it was as good as Jesus so he could wish to keep him and his wish will come true. I also think Marty will be happier to know that Judd won't hurt Shiloh while Shiloh is with Marty.