Readers' Comments

Shiloh
by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

Wednesday, December 19
If you submitted a comment about Shiloh on December 19, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:

November 26 27 28 29 30
December 3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21

From:
Emily
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Everyone
What kind of lessons do you think that Marty learned? I think one of biggest lessons that Marty learned was not to lie especially to his family.
I recommend this book if you like dogs and action!

From:
Holden
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Andy
I think Marty and Judd's agreement is unfair on Marty. Two dollars an hour is a bad deal. I thought even Judd would be fair. Since I've finished Shiloh, I thought I would make a final recommendation. I recommend this book to animal lovers and kids.

From:
Haris
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: everyone
My feelings weren't like Marty's becausee
I think Marty shouldn't have kept Shiloh
because it wasn't his dog.I think Marty
should've returned Shiloh to Judd because
it wasn't his porperty. I wouldn't recommend this book to
others who like adventure because this book didn't have any
action in it. What do you think?

From:
Brandon
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: everyone
Hi everyone, this book is recommended to anyone who is mean to animals and is the only person on earth who has no care for animals. This book was so boring for me because I never liked reading animal books. I will never recommend this book to my friend's. This book is 5 stars.

From:
Eric
Grade 5
John T. Tuck
Burlington, Ontario To: Everyone
Hi, Everybody I was wondering would you recommend this book to others. I would not recommend this book to others because there are so many boring parts in this book like when Marty has to do is boring paper route. I would only recommend this book to some animal dude who are obsessed with animals and what they do every single day. I mean it is so boring to read about the life of a country family who are so poor they couldn't spend forty measly dollars on a dog. I mean give the poor creature a chance to live man! I think that if they are so poor they should sell their house and live in a apartment. I think that if I had to give this book stars out of ten I think i'd give it about one and a half stars. Some other people might like this book but I only like fast paced action that completely knocks you right off your feet. I think that this book is more good for girls then it is for boys. I think that the best part of this book is when Shiloh got all chewed up and almost very closly died of infection.

From:
Michael
Grade 5
Sheridan Elementary
Petoskey, MI To: Everyone
You guys sure see the glass half empty today.How could it be boring with all the suspense? How about some good comments?

From:
Kali
Grade 5
Sheridan Elementary
Petoskey, MI To: Haris
I don't agree with you that Marty shouldn't have kept Shiloh because if he hadn't kept him what would the story be based on? I also don't agree with you because if Marty hadn't kept Shiloh, Shiloh probably would have gotten hurt almmost everyday. I also don't agree with you that the book didn't have any adventure in it, and I would recommend it to anybody that wanted to read a good adventure book.

From:
Amit
Grade 4
Herod Elementary
Houston, TX To: Everyone
I really liked this chapter because it taught me that if you really want something there is no way you are going to get it the easy way you really have to work hard for it until you get it you can not quit. Sometimes you have to do something bad like Marty did but it will all work out just like it did in the story.I really liked the story somtimes it was sad but it was a great book to read.I would like to read it again.

From:
Precious
Grade 4
Herod Elementary
Houston, TX To: Everyone
My class has just got done with Shiloh. I liked the book very much. My favorite characters were Marty and Shiloh they were the best characters.I think Marty did the right thing to Judd cause he was a mean and uncaring.So to every one if you have not read this book you should.Good bye...

From:
Dani
Grade 4
Herod Elementary
Houston, TX To: Everyone
At the end of this chapter 15 I felt happy and reyjoysed that
Marty got Shiloh .The reasen I felt happy was because
when I got my dog I had to work to get him to.I also felt
reyjoysed that Judd let Marty buy Shiloh without money
but with work.On pg. 144 finaly Judd looks like he gets
freindly.

From:
Phoebe
To: Everyone
Great comments everyone! I would like to hear more about how you felt at the end of the book. Were your feelings anything like Marty's?

From:
Andy
To: Everyone
I think it's fun to read a lot of different opinions. If you agree with someone, explain why. If you disagree with someone, explain why.


Shiloh by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor
Wednesday, December 19 If you submitted a comment about Shiloh on December 19, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:
November 26 27 28 29 30 December 3 4 5 6 7 10 11 12 13 14 17 18 19 20 21

From: Emily Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Everyone What kind of lessons do you think that Marty learned? I think one of biggest lessons that Marty learned was not to lie especially to his family. I recommend this book if you like dogs and action!

From: Holden Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Andy I think Marty and Judd's agreement is unfair on Marty. Two dollars an hour is a bad deal. I thought even Judd would be fair. Since I've finished Shiloh, I thought I would make a final recommendation. I recommend this book to animal lovers and kids.

From: Haris Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: everyone My feelings weren't like Marty's becausee I think Marty shouldn't have kept Shiloh because it wasn't his dog.I think Marty should've returned Shiloh to Judd because it wasn't his porperty. I wouldn't recommend this book to others who like adventure because this book didn't have any action in it. What do you think?

From: Brandon Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: everyone Hi everyone, this book is recommended to anyone who is mean to animals and is the only person on earth who has no care for animals. This book was so boring for me because I never liked reading animal books. I will never recommend this book to my friend's. This book is 5 stars.

From: Eric Grade 5 John T. Tuck Burlington, Ontario	To: Everyone Hi, Everybody I was wondering would you recommend this book to others. I would not recommend this book to others because there are so many boring parts in this book like when Marty has to do is boring paper route. I would only recommend this book to some animal dude who are obsessed with animals and what they do every single day. I mean it is so boring to read about the life of a country family who are so poor they couldn't spend forty measly dollars on a dog. I mean give the poor creature a chance to live man! I think that if they are so poor they should sell their house and live in a apartment. I think that if I had to give this book stars out of ten I think i'd give it about one and a half stars. Some other people might like this book but I only like fast paced action that completely knocks you right off your feet. I think that this book is more good for girls then it is for boys. I think that the best part of this book is when Shiloh got all chewed up and almost very closly died of infection.

From: Michael Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone You guys sure see the glass half empty today.How could it be boring with all the suspense? How about some good comments?

From: Kali Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary Petoskey, MI	To: Haris I don't agree with you that Marty shouldn't have kept Shiloh because if he hadn't kept him what would the story be based on? I also don't agree with you because if Marty hadn't kept Shiloh, Shiloh probably would have gotten hurt almmost everyday. I also don't agree with you that the book didn't have any adventure in it, and I would recommend it to anybody that wanted to read a good adventure book.

From: Amit Grade 4 Herod Elementary Houston, TX	To: Everyone I really liked this chapter because it taught me that if you really want something there is no way you are going to get it the easy way you really have to work hard for it until you get it you can not quit. Sometimes you have to do something bad like Marty did but it will all work out just like it did in the story.I really liked the story somtimes it was sad but it was a great book to read.I would like to read it again.

From: Precious Grade 4 Herod Elementary Houston, TX	To: Everyone My class has just got done with Shiloh. I liked the book very much. My favorite characters were Marty and Shiloh they were the best characters.I think Marty did the right thing to Judd cause he was a mean and uncaring.So to every one if you have not read this book you should.Good bye...

From: Dani Grade 4 Herod Elementary Houston, TX	To: Everyone At the end of this chapter 15 I felt happy and reyjoysed that Marty got Shiloh .The reasen I felt happy was because when I got my dog I had to work to get him to.I also felt reyjoysed that Judd let Marty buy Shiloh without money but with work.On pg. 144 finaly Judd looks like he gets freindly.

From: Phoebe	To: Everyone Great comments everyone! I would like to hear more about how you felt at the end of the book. Were your feelings anything like Marty's?

From: Andy	To: Everyone I think it's fun to read a lot of different opinions. If you agree with someone, explain why. If you disagree with someone, explain why.