Readers' Comments



Tuck Everlasting by Natalie Babbit
Tuesday, October 15 If you submitted a comment about Tuck Everlasting on October 15, it should appear below. To view comments for another day, use these links:
September 18 19 20 23 24 25 26 27 30 October 1 2 3 4 7 8 9 10 11 14 15

From: Aaron Grade 5 Ralya Elementary School Haslett, MI	To: Carmen Hi carmen did you finish the book ?I can't belive winnie got away with swithing placese with Mae. And if you read the Epilogue you'll find somthing very sad. Please Write back!

From: Carmen	To: Everyone Hello! Welcome to the final day of our Tuck Everlasting discussion. I really hope you use your time today to look at the novel as a whole. Did you like it? Did you like its message? Write what you think.

From: Raoul	To: Everyone Hey, if you're not quite done with the book yet, don't worry about it. Still post comments about whatever you just read. Thanks!

From: ramone Grade grade5 Mata Intermediate School Houston, TX	To: chelsea I can't belive Winnie Foster died if that was me I would drank the water instead of pouring on the frog. I wonder if they are coming out with tuck everlasting II I hope they do because I want to know if Winnies kids are going to be in it.

From: Evie, Taylor Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Niko Why do you think that the movie would be better than the book? We think that the book is better than the movie because you can picture more. The movie is showing you the picture & in the book you can mostly picture the descriptions.

From: Shelly Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Mike Winnie did not drink the water because she probably wanted to live and die like a regular person. Winnie wanted to marry Jesse but she also wanted to die and see heaven and meet God. I would have done the same. What about you? How would you feel?

From: Rachel Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone Why do you think Winnie didn't drink the water? She had really wanted to be with Jesse before.

From: Justin Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone What happened to Jesse and Miles? Also how did Winnie die and what are her children's names?

From: Justin Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone What happened to Jesse and Miles? Also how did Winnie die and what are her children's names?

From: Adam Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Niko I disagree with you, I think this book is very cool! What do you think about Jesse and Miles, where did they go? I think that they are traveling around the world, what do you think?

From: Erica Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone I can't wait until the next book comes out because I want to find out what happens to Jesse and Myles. Also I want to find who was the man Winnie married or who her children were.I also enjoyed this book because of the feelings that the characters have. Did you enjoy this book?And why?

From: Josh Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Marco If you chose to live forever you would never know how it is to die and you might lose all your friends. Now what do you think about living forever?

From: Rachel Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Ben Well, I don't think that Mae will suffocate, but Angus said he shot himself but it barely left a mark. So I think that she won't die or even get pain.

From: Adam Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Marco I would drink from the spring beacause I would like to see what the future would be like and I would like to do things that most people would have to be out of their mind to do!

From: Nick Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Kylee I agree with you. Sometimes life can be a prison.Living forever is something you can`t escape.

From: Kelsey Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Johntranette I think you are right about Mae. I don't think she should get hung because she was just protecting herself and her family from the man in the yellow suit. He shouldn't have barged in to their house and insulted them like that. Wouldn't you think he would have known better not to do that? Do you think Natalie Babbitt is a good author? Why or why not?

From: Shelly Grade 5 Sheridan Elementary School Petoskey, MI	To: Everyone I enjoyed this book very much because it was full of action ,romance ,adventure and interest. I will definitely want to read other books written by Natalie Babbitt because she is a wonderful author and she makes the story so interesting and so real and fun to picture in your mind. What do you think about Natalie Babbitt? If you were Winnie would you have drank the water? I would of because I would want to see heaven. But then I would also want to marry Jesse because he sounds nice and he would like me if I were Winnie.How do you think the story would of ended if Winnie was to drink the water? Now that we have ended the story, what did you think ? I think this is one of my favorite books.